American vs Italian food & cuisine

Chicken is the top protein by far, with beef and pork trailing behind, and cheese (especially cheddar and mozzarella) is practically everywhere. In American stores, potatoes show up in every guise – fresh, mashed, frozen fries, chips. Sugar and corn syrup slip into sodas, condiments, and nearly every snack on the shelf.

Regional identity is another hallmark. Like Chinese or Indian food, Italian cuisine is deeply regional, but here diversity is central to national pride, with locals fiercely guarding distinctions.

Meals also follow structure, though rules vary. At home, dinner may be just pasta, salad, and fruit. Traditionally and in formal settings, courses are small, distinct, and served in sequence.

Pancakes and pizza are other carbohydrate favorites. Pancakes are fluffy, baking powder–leavened cakes served here with butter, syrup, or fruit. Pizza, brought by Italian immigrants, spread nationwide with regional styles like New York thin crust and Chicago deep dish.

Mac and cheese is a comfort classic of pasta baked in cheese sauce, now a staple in every kitchen. Breakfast cereals, invented in the U.S., became a quick breakfast, especially for children.

Corn remains central to Southern cooking and fast food, eaten as cornbread, grits, tortillas, popcorn, or sweet corn. Rice’s role is smaller, but is key in Southern, Cajun, Creole, and Asian American dishes, from jambalaya to fried rice.

Italians eat pasta often – three times a week or more – but in modest portions (80–100 grams). Every village has at least one traditional pasta, adding up to over 350 shapes. Wheat also underpins breads, usually rustic with few ingredients, though styles vary: Ligurian focaccia, Puglian Altamura, unsalted pane toscano.

Pizza belongs to this wheat spectrum too, related to focaccia and schiacciata, but stands apart as a full meal and Italy’s most iconic export. Italians love it, yet most eat it weekly rather than daily, countering common misconceptions.

When rice is featured on menus, it’s most likely arborio and carnaroli varieties, which absorb liquids and remain pleasantly tender. Rice is used in risottos, arancinis, risi e bisi.

Polenta is uniquely popular as the main corn product – consumed creamy, set and sliced, grilled, or even fried.

Americans consume sweet potatoes more frequently and in a wider variety of ways than people in most countries.

Fruits are snacks and breakfast additions to cereal and yogurt, they feature desserts – apples, cherry pies, cobblers, cakes, ice cream toppings, juices, smoothies, and sauces – apple sauce, cranberry sauce, chutneys.  In the U.S., a big chunk of what counts as ‘fruit consumption’ is actually fruit juice, especially orange, which for decades was seen as a breakfast essential.

Vegetables are tied to season and prepared simply with olive oil, herbs, cheese, or bread, keeping them distinct. Italians often highlight one or two vegetables at a time: asparagus, peas, and artichokes in spring; peppers, eggplants, and tomatoes in summer; broccoli, cauliflower, and mushrooms in fall; carrots, squash, and savoy cabbage in winter. Unique favorites include friarielli, cicoria, fennel, cavolo nero, and zucchini blossoms.

Mushrooms, especially porcini, are beloved, as are truffles from Piedmont. Truffle hunting, once done with pigs, now relies on trained dogs.

Fruit is ever-present, fresh, dried, in jams, or baked. Italian desserts often use fruit in tarts, pastries, and gelato. Grapes serve both wine and balsamic vinegar, the latter aged in wooden barrels for 12–25 years. True balsamic from Modena is dark, sweet, and versatile, its long maturation sometimes becoming a family heirloom.

Meat is associated with American identity, strength, reinforced through social and media narratives, though concerns about health, sustainability, and animal welfare are beginning to challenge consumption patterns.

Barbecue culture, BBQ ribs, slow-cooked pork or beef ribs with smoky barbecue sauce are super American foods. Americans now eat 50 billion burgers a year. Many assume burgers and hot dogs are low-end foods, but in the U.S., chefs now elevate them with dry-aged beef, foie gras, or artisan buns, making them gourmet, Instagram-worthy, and still culturally familiar.

Turkey is the centerpiece of Thanksgiving. Outside of holidays, turkey isn’t eaten as frequently, especially whole. Instead, it appears as sliced deli meat, ground (a leaner substitute for beef), or as sausage.

Fried chicken was not invented in the U.S., but it was transformed there into the globally recognized dish we know today.  In the U.S. South, fried chicken became distinctive: heavily seasoned, with a crispy crust, deep-fried in oil.

Today, American meat traditions sit at a crossroads: cherished for tradition, questioned for their climate impact.  Beef consumption gradually declines, chicken rises, and new options like blended proteins and lab-grown meat emerge alongside growing environmental awareness.

Italian cuisine is known for curing and preserving pork. Prosciuttos Parma and San Daniele, or salamis like Genoa and Sopressata, showthe transform meat into lasting specialties. Meat often serves as flavoring rather than a dominant center.

Other meats are rather regional: beef in bistecca alla fiorentina and ossobuco; veal in Milanese and Roman dishes; lamb in Central and Southern classics like abbacchio alla romana. Poultry, though less central, features in rustic recipes like pollo alla cacciatora.

Seasonal game adds variety, with wild boar, venison, hare, pheasant, quail, and rabbit enjoyed locally.

Asian American communities, especially in Hawaii and along the West Coast, helped make raw and grilled fish more common. Caribbean and Latin American communities contributed to the popularity of ceviche, salted fish, and other coastal favorites, especially in Florida and urban areas.

Shrimp, tuna, and salmon are staples in the U.S., shrimp is the most popular seafood overall. Canned tuna is the second most popular seafood product. Of those Americans who eat canned tuna, the vast majority, 83 percent, eat it for lunch. In fact, canned tuna is the only regularly consumed seafood at lunch.

Distinct regional specialties highlight natural flavors. Sardinia and Sicily grate cured mullet roe (bottarga) over pasta; Liguria layers or marinates anchovies; Venice serves baccalà mantecato, a whipped salted cod spread; southern regions savor raw sea urchins, especially in Puglia. Crudo di mare – raw scallops, shrimp, or octopus with lemon and olive oil – also reflects Italy’s love of pure seafood, as does the popular fritto misto di mare of lightly fried fish and shellfish.

Cheddar consistently ranks as the #1 or #2 most-produced cheese. The U.S. cheddar is milder, moister, and more uniform than traditional English versions. Philadelphia cream cheese is an American invention that has become globally popular.

Americans have a strong cultural sweet tooth, and their desserts tend to be very sweet and indulgent, often using large amounts of sugar, butter, and cream. The portion sizes of desserts also tend to be larger than in many cultures. Generally, desserts focus on ease, comfort, and sharing, not ceremony.

Northern Italian oils from Liguria and Lombardy tend to be mild, delicate, and buttery, while oils from Southern Puglia, Sicily, and Calabria are bolder, robust, peppery, and often have sweet or herbal notes. Though Italian cuisine also uses butter, olive oil is a must-have kitchen staple.

Nuts are very diverse: they feature pesto sauce; are served with pasta; chopped nuts are used in salad dressings, cookies, tarts, and nougats. Italian gelato often includes nut-based flavors of pistachio or hazelnut.

Italian sweets are usually less sweet, with a focus on nuts, ricotta, chestnuts, and fresh or dried fruits. Many classics – such as tiramisù, panna cotta, or gelato – use few, high-quality ingredients.